From Thinkprogress:
Strangley absent from the photo-op was Idol finalist Elliot Yamin.Bush Works for Lasting Peace in the Middle East:
This afternoon at a joint press conference with Prime Minister Tony Blair, President Bush said he would “make every effort to achieve a lasting peace” in the Middle East. He got started right away. Here are some photos from the Oval Office immediately after the event:
This of course could be a mere coincidence, Yamin probaby figured he could visit the President the next time the Idol's are invited. (Never mind the fact that this is the first time in five seasons this has occured, and apparently only happened this time because one of Idol Winner Taylor Hicks' Grade school teachers is now Laura Bush's Press Secretary).
Now, I'm not one to speculate - (yeah, right) but maybe Elliot was just sick and didn't want to give the President something he had. Yeah - that's the ticket. It probably had nothing what-so-ever to do with the current conflicts in the middle-east in Israel or Iraq. I mean, it's not like Elliot has any particular interest in those countries - except for the fact that his father Shaoul Yamin is of Iraqi descent, while his mother Claudette Goldberg-Yamin is Jewish-American.
Methinks there's a big fat pink elephant in the Oval Office. Or rather - missing from the Oval Office. Elliot Yamin.
But then again, maybe I'm completely offbase. Maybe this has nothing to do with Elliot's choice, maybe he didn't decide to be left out - and that decision was made for him. Maybe it was the Secret Service, or White House Chief of Staff Joshua Bolten - or Turdblossom - they do have to protect the President from any undesirable persons, don't they?
Y'know - people with like bumper-stickers and stuff.
"I wish she'd stay away. Crawford's a Republican town, and she's a dumb Democrat," Westerfield, a lifelong Crawford resident, said Friday while sitting on a bench outside a gas station on Main Street.
Heartwarming isn't it? She's only been camped outside President Bush's doorstep for months to ask one question "What Noble Cause did my Son Die For?" - and George has been ducking her the entire time. Brave man, that George.
If you or I were one of the "safe" Idol's who actually did meet the President, would you or wouldn't you feel the urge to ask Cindy's question for her?
Or maybe instead ask one of a half million other possible questions like "Mr. President...
- How could you endorse and allow torture by attempting to dodge the Geneva Conventions, don't you realize how that endangers our own troops? (Troops like Menchaka and Tucker)
- How could you authorize the Iraq War when all legitimate information pointed to Saddam already being disarmed?
- Even if you yourself disputed of the facts and intelligence data at the time (and have since been shown to be completely wrong), shouldn't you have erred on the side of caution and let the inspectors finish doing their jobs, rather than destroying the infrastruction of Iraq and causing the deaths of over 50,000 people?
- Is "Just Wait" really what you'd call an effective long term foreign policy?
- Is it a Civil War Yet when people start talking about a Coup against the Prime Minister?
- What happened to our 8.8 Billion dollars and can we have a refund since we obviously failed to buy Maliki's loyality away from his fellow Shia's in Hezbollah with it?
- Just how big was the federal deficit when you came into office again? Oh yeah, that's right - we didn't have one.
- Why's New Orleans still
so fucked up- uh - a total disaster? - Why do Donald Rumsfeld and Micheal Chertoff still have jobs? Do they have copies of compromising pictures of somebody? Did they forge the Killian Memos or the Niger-Uranium Document or something?
- How's that Social Security Reform Plan coming along?
- So, do you plan to wait to act until Israel has killed every living thing in Southern Lebanon - or just most of the children?
- Now that your Vice President's Chief of Staff has been indicted for perjury, your head of Domestic Procurement prosecuted for bribery and corruption and your Chief Domestic Policy Advisor arrested for shoplifting - do you still think you've brought "honor and integrity" back to the White House?
- Just what kind of shoes did Condi buy while the people of New Orleans were drowning?
- If the New York Times should be prosecuted for revealing (already public) information about the Bank Data program, what exactly should happen to columnist Robert Novak for revealing an undercover CIA agent and her entire operation which was working to prevent Iran from obtaining a Nuclear Bomb?
- Why haven't we caught or killed Osama Bin Laden yet? I thought we were gonna "Smoke 'em out"!
- So do you think the Rapture has already started, or we still have a couple more years for our stocks to mature?
- Isn't it great, now that Zarqawi is dead - our troops can start coming home (as long as they call "home" Baghdad, that is) ?
- Hey, I forgot this phone number of this girl I called once on Saturday, November 21st 2004 at 1:37 am Pacific Standard Time - could have the NSA get that back for me?
But how could you not? How could let an oppurtunity to get an answer, any answer - even one of Bush's typical bullshit answers like "Freedom is on the March" - slip away?
I don't know if Elliot had a cold that day, if he had strong enough feelings that he didn't want to be in the proximity of George Bush, or the reverse - members of the Bush Adminstration felt he couldn't be trusted not to pressure or embarass the President - I just don't know.
I'm just saying, whether you approve or disagree with George Bush's Presidency, if you had a chance to speak your mind directly to the man - even in the middle of a photo-op of this type - would you pass it up?
I know I wouldn't.
What would you ask him?
Vyan
Update: People Magazine (not a News source I generally frequent) has a report up that indicates that Yamin simply overslept and only missed the photo session.
Elliott Yamin missed the first part of the visit with the President. About five minutes after it started, he was seen racing down the hall toward the Oval Office, wiping his brow and saying, "Phew!" "He was sleeping!" Young explains, adding that the Idols - who have been on the "American Idols Live" tour since July 6 - arrived in Washington, D.C., at 5:30 a.m., and that some of them have been having a hard time sleeping on the bus that takes them from city to city.Leave it to AI to be banal to the end - that is if you believe this "story" from People. /snark.

That's the new mantra coming from Alberto Gonzales and some Republicans on the hill as a result of the Hamdan (
hat she hasn't really shown her own personality on stage yet and has instead been regurgitating generic stage moves, but it can't be said that she hasn't sang her guts out.
Patrice's performance of "My Iron Lung" by Radiohead was a ballsy choice - but a great one. I'm not a big Radiohead fan, but this song had the kind of drama and dynamics that Patrice needed to show. She's already proven she can sing, but can she stop and audience dead in it's tracks with just a look! Can she bring them to a fever pitch and drop them to their knees? That's what you get from someone like Eddie Vedder or Bono in their prime.
But this time- this time, all I can say is that her rendition of "I'm not an addict" by K's Choice was a snooze fest. Zayra simply doesn't have the vocal quality or magnetism to just stand their with a microphone without moving and truly deliver chills with a song. She aint got it. Dilana can do it (and has), even Dana has shown she could do it last night. But Zayra brought nothing to the table tonight except possible eyestrain with yet another radioactive outfit.
Last up was Phil, and I've had my doubts about him. Mr head-bob seems to be in his own world and this performance he finally let us join him with a song by Failure. It was a real quirky song - right up his alley, but what got me was his physical performance. He completley took command of the stage - and I could absolutely see what he was doing work in a heavier context like Supernova's with an EMO twist. I'm not an Emo fan, but there are millions of them out there - and they would absolutely love to see a band with some chops and a unique, different and daring singer leading them. Just think about
The excuse that Phil just didn't have the "commitment" was just plain lame. Where the hell did that shit come from? If it was so important that they let Phil go because of it don't you think they would have mentioned it to him before? What is this - a rerun of the sacking of Dave Mustaine from Metallica? ("Hey dude, wake up - you're out of the band - here's you bus ticket home - cya!) That crap has caused him issues to this very day (as was shown in Metallica documentary "Some Kind of Monster")
We didn't manage to pull this off until the first four performances had already gone by - so the first thing I saw was Magni doing "Heroes". He sounded good, but let me lodge a little complaint about so-called "singer-songwriters" who never freaking PLAY THEIR GUITAR. It's not an ornament dude, either play it or put it down. I've been singing and playing guitar for over 20 years, and if I had an opputunity like this I'd bloody well *play* something - in fact, I'd play some lead guitar just because I can, and it's something Supernova actually needs as far as I'm concerned. I mean, Gilby's cool and all - but he ain't SLASH. (The little guitar segment during this weeks Reality Episode made that abundantly clear)
Jill Rocked the House with Gilby on "Brown Sugar", she looked totally comfortable and in her element. Good job. He still has the "Bluesy" strike going against her compared to what Supernova is ultimately trying to do - but in her cause she does bridge the gap and does so easily. Josh may be on his last legs, but Jill is standing tall.
Ok - as I type this (from work) - I've taken a look at some of the performances I missed last night via the RS website and the first one up is Lukas doing "Bittersweat Melody" and as usually he has his own take on the song. Unlike his previous ballad in week 2, this one was much more effective. He has quite a few limitations in his voice, but like Dilana, it makes him standout. He could do without the Billy Idol snear though - that was week 1 dude. Also, again with the guitar playing that can't be heard -- enough with that shit already ok? Either let the man be heard, have him play somethng unique, or put the damn guitar down.
Toby's performance - I couldn't get to play online so I'll have to deal with it when I get home -(
Team leader Magni also butted heads with Jill the Italian powerhouse on the issue of songwriting methods. Magni is one who likes to listen to the song over and over to let it soak in - Jill likes to try out different riffs as she listens and you can't do both at the same time. Magni has already written and recorded six albums in Iceland, so he's pretty comfortable and confident on his methods -- Jill was a little rattled and frustrated by him, to say the least.
When time came to perform their songs for Tommy Lee and the Supernova boys - the Dilana/Lukas/Storm group was up first and gave them
The third and final track was the Magni/Jill magnum opus - which featured a syncopated vocal rythm and lush four part harmonies. Rather than being another over the top "Stop/Go" vocal excersize in excess - this one seemed to also blow the SN boys away.